Close-up of a slice of magic custard cake with three distinct layers and a dusting of powdered sugar, styled for a recipe card.

This magic custard cake is truly enchanting. Three velvety custard layers magically appear during the baking process to deliver a silky sweet cake that everyone will rave about.

Jump to Recipe

Prep Time15

Cook Time45

Total Time4

Servings

Slice of magic custard cake with a golden top and custardy center, labeled with “Magic Custard Cake” text.

I first made this magic custard cake on a whim, curious to see if the rumors were true. The method felt almost too easy—egg yolks whisked with sugar until creamy, a swirl of melted butter and vanilla, flour folded in, then a gentle stream of warm milk and cream.

Whipped egg whites are floated over the top, and in the oven, the magic happens. The heat teases apart the mixture into layers that feel like they were made separately… but weren’t.

Magic Custard Cake is a a dessert that defies logic and delivers pure comfort. For another flavor variation on this magic cake, try our pumpkin magic cake.

Magic Custard Cake Ingredients

Flat lay of ingredients for magic custard cake including eggs, milk, butter, flour, sugar, and vanilla extract, all labeled.

You will need:

4 large eggs, separated, at room temperature
1 cup of baker’s sugar (superfine sugar)
½ cup of salted butter, melted and cooled
2 teaspoons of vanilla extract
1 cup all-purpose flour
1 ½ cups of whole milk, lukewarm
½ cup of heavy cream, lukewarm

NOTE: Baker’s sugar is not the same as granulated sugar or confectioner’s sugar. Look for sugar that is labeled superfine or caster sugar. If you cannot find this type of sugar, you can make your own by running one cup plus two teaspoons of granulated sugar through a food processor for 30 seconds.

Custard has such a velvety smooth texture and is a delicious base for so many desserts. Try our custard pie and cream puff dessert for two other custard-based treats.

Tried and Tested Pro Tips

Get the complete step-by-step instructions in the recipe card at the end of this post.

The key to success is respecting the batter’s two personalities—runny custard base meets airy whites.

Pro tips for egg whites with a bowl of fluffy egg whites and text tips for achieving best results. — Whip up perfect egg whites every time—start with a dry glass or metal bowl, and use room-temperature eggs for that fluffy, cloud-like texture.

The batter will be very runny and thin, and that is the consistency you want for the magic layering to happen.

You’ll want to whisk the egg whites into the custard batter gently, so they don’t fully disappear.

Step-by-step collage showing how to fold fluffy egg whites into the cake batter, with whisking and bubbles on top.

It’s important to use an 8×8 square pan — as it will achieve the three distinct layers. A larger pan will spread the cake batter too thin for the custard layer to form. The batter won’t fit in a smaller pan.

When baked, you’ll know it’s done if the top is golden and the center is just a bit jiggly (think gentle wobble, not soup).

Serving Ideas

Allow the cake to sit for two to three hours before serving. Then. dust the top of the cake with confectioner’s sugar and add fresh berries for the perfect presentation. For an extra indulgence, add a spoonful of homemade whipped cream.

It’s best to remove the pieces from the pan one at a time rather than trying to remove the entire cake at once. To slice the cake cleanly, pop your knife in the freezer to cool it, and it should cut the cake easily.

How To Store

This magic three-layer custard cake recipe is best eaten right away, but you can store it in the refrigerator in an airtight container or covered in aluminum foil for up to two days. Freezing isn’t recommended.

One Easy Batter, Three Gorgeous Layers

Final Thoughts

Baking this magic custard cake recipe is one of those rare kitchen moments where simple ingredients truly surprise you. After years of testing and fine-tuning, I can confidently say this method delivers consistent layers—a light sponge top, silky custard center, and firm base—every single time.

Whether you’re making it for a holiday, a dinner party, or just because, follow the tips above—especially for whipping perfect egg whites—and you’ll have a dessert that feels both impressive and comforting.

If you make this magic custard cake, I’d love to hear how it turns out. Share your results in the comments or tag me so I can see your gorgeous layers in action.

More Cake Recipes