Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot (with RumChata and Fireball)

This Cinnamon Toast Crunch shot tastes exactly like the cereal. Creamy, cinnamony, and just sweet enough to make you want another one, it is equal parts RumChata and Fireball whisky. Two ingredients, no measuring beyond a jigger, and done in under two minutes.

close up shot of Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shots topped with a cinnamon toast crunch

RumChata brings the cream and sweetness while Fireball handles the cinnamon heat. Together they nail that sugary cereal flavor better than you would expect from something so simple. It is the shot that always surprises people at the table.

Serve it chilled with a cinnamon sugar rim and a piece of actual Cinnamon Toast Crunch on the glass if you want to commit to the bit. Or just pour and shoot. Either way works.

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot Ingredients

Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot raw ingredients that are labeled

This rich, velvety shot is filled with a sinfully sweet concoction that’ll transport your taste buds right into a childhood morning.

The blend of RumChata liqueur, cinnamon whisky, and fluffy whipped cream creates an explosion of tastes reminiscent of the beloved cereal.

You’ll need:

2 ounces of RumChata liquor
2 ounces of Fireball cinnamon whisky
Spray can of whipped cream
Cinnamon toast crunch cereal
Cinnamon sugar, for the rim

PRO TIP:

RumChata is a creamy liqueur with cream, sugar, rum, cinnamon, and vanilla flavors. It is similar to Irish cream but with a cinnamon flavor. The flavor in this shot can be likened to the milk left in the cereal bowl after eating cinnamon toast crunch.

Substitutions And Additions

VANILLA: Add a vanilla twist to this delicious shot with a dash of vanilla vodka or vanilla extract.

CINNAMON WHISKY: Any brand of cinnamon whisky, including Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Fire or Jim Beam Kentucky Fire Whiskey, would work in this RumChata cinnamon toast crunch shot recipe.

RUMCHATA: While RumChata adds creaminess and a hint of vanilla to the shot, you can try other cream liqueurs like Baileys, Kahlúa, or even an almond milk cream liqueur for a unique twist.

How To Make This Cinnamon Toast Crunch Shot Recipe

This tasty shot comes together quickly by combining the liqueur in a cocktail shaker and pouring it into a shot glass rimmed with cinnamon sugar. Top with whipped cream and crushed cereal, and you’re all set to serve it.

Follow our step-by-step instructions below.

OUR RECIPE DEVELOPER SAYS

This recipe makes two shots. If you need more, you can easily double the recipe.

STEP ONE: Use a clean, damp paper towel to moisten the rim of two shot glasses.

Place the cinnamon sugar in a shallow dish and dip the rim of the shot glass into the cinnamon sugar mixture.

glass rim being dipped into a cinnamon sugar

STEP TWO: Fill a cocktail shaker with ice.

STEP THREE: Add two ounces of RumChata and two ounces of Fireball whisky to the cocktail shaker. Shake vigorously.

rum chata and fireball whiskey added to a shaker

STEP FOUR: Divide the mixture between the two shot glasses.

STEP FIVE: Top with a squirt of whipped cream and a piece of cinnamon toast crunch cereal.

PRO TIP:

The whipped cream makes it a little more difficult to drink the shot in one swoop, but the creaminess does cut some of the spiciness from the whisky.

whipped cream and a piece of cinnamon toast crunch garnished on top of the shot

More Easy Party Treats

If you love this shot, there are a few other recipes worth saving. Cinnamon roll Fireball shots have that same quick, creamy, cinnamon-forward feel, just with cream soda instead of RumChata, so they’re a great choice when you want something simple and easy to scale for a party.

Fireball and cream soda is another one I reach for when I want the warmth of cinnamon whisky without a lot of extra ingredients.

And if you want to take the same cereal-inspired idea a step further, Cinnamon Toast Crunch cocktail uses RumChata and Fireball in a cozy, sippable drink, while Cinnamon Toast Crunch poke cake brings those same familiar cinnamon cereal notes into an easy cake mix dessert.

You can browse all of my Fireball recipes in one spot, from sweet desserts and drinks to savory dishes, with plenty of holiday and summer inspiration.

MORE SHOT RECIPES

All Recipes

How To Make Jello Shots

All Recipes

Fireball Jello Shots

Storage

IN THE FRIDGE/FREEZER: This Fireball RumChata shot needs to be served immediately, and we don’t recommend trying to store the mixture for any length of time.

Why We Love This Recipe

NOSTALGIC FLAVOR: This shot captures the beloved taste of Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal, bringing a nostalgic and comforting flavor to your glass.

QUICK AND EASY: With just a few simple ingredients and easy-to-follow steps, this shot is a breeze to make, making it perfect for gatherings or a quick sweet treat.

CREAMY INDULGENCE: The combination of RumChata and cinnamon creates a smooth texture with a delightful hint of cinnamon spice, making it an indulgent drink.

This tasty cinnamon toast crunch shot is sweet, spicy, and oh-so-satisfying. The combination of the cinnamon sugar rim, creamy RumChata, and spicy cinnamon whisky makes it taste just like the sweet milk in the bottom of a cinnamon toast crunch cereal bowl.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I make this dessert shot ahead of time and keep it in a container in the fridge?

We don’t recommend storing this creamy drink in the fridge. Shake it up right when you are ready to drink it.

Can I use whipped topping instead of a squirt whipped cream?

If you don’t have a squirt whipped cream on hand, whipped topping will work just fine for these tasty shots.

How can I get the cinnamon sugar to stick to the rim of the glass?

Coating the shot glass rim with water or a bit of clear corn syrup works best to help the sugar to stick to the rim of the glass.